Reviews for If She Fell
| beaweasley2 |
2006.10.09 - 02:17PM |
5: Like a seed dropped by a skybird |
Signed |
| Terrific!
I enjoy this little tail quiet a bit. Thanks! |
| harmony_bites |
2006.05.16 - 12:33AM |
8: For Good |
Signed |
| I thought this was a lot of fun. I find it hard to see Harry this way--oh, I can see him very much wanting to be the family man, just hard to see him as trying to cram Hermione, then Ginny into a mold they wouldn't fit and being so presumptuous about it. That said, I loved the Remus/Ginny romance, and the theme of finding what fits and being true to yourself--that rose as a metaphor was perfect. And as a HG/SS shipper, how can I not love your Snape? I loved how learning Harry was Remus' rival brought him around so quickly. |
| Bemidia |
2006.04.01 - 07:53AM |
8: For Good |
Signed |
| This was such a lovely story. I almost cried when Ginny left Remus on the porch. :(
And Harry came off as such a bastard. (I'm alright with that though.)
Good job!! Great story. |
| Clara Minutes |
2005.11.07 - 11:37PM |
8: For Good |
Signed |
| I'm so glad Percy made it. I'm not a huge fan of canon Percy, but I think in this case I can overlook that. You are a very talented writer. Thanks for sharing your works with us. ~Clara |
| whimsy007 |
2005.11.04 - 05:45AM |
8: For Good |
Signed |
Not a bad story with some very good characterizations, but I dislike OCs whose main purpose is to have everyone happily paired up at the end. I would have been happier with a Harry still trying to find his place in the world, baffled by a failed marriage to one of his closest friends who cheated on him with someone he dislikes, then rebuffed by the only other woman he's been close to. Not quite as happy an ending, but it rings truer.
Author's Response: Actually, Harry isn't "paired up happily" with anyone. He has a date, that's all. He's not baffled by the end of his marriage - he had two other fics to understand why his marriage to Hermione went south ("If She Fell" and "In A Lifetime"). My OC's purpose was to step between Ginny and Remus for a time. |
| spaz141 |
2005.10.02 - 12:05AM |
8: For Good |
Anonymous |
| Ooo a happy ending AND a wedding. Squee! Thanks. I enjoyed. |
| spaz141 |
2005.10.01 - 11:53PM |
7: I Have Been Changed For Good |
Anonymous |
| Yay for assertive Ginny! Thanks. |
| azulkan |
2005.09.28 - 08:46PM |
8: For Good |
Signed |
| Loved this almost as much as 10 years after and its sequel. |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 [Next]
|